November 16 | Brittany Adair Beitzel
Sunday Night Cabaret Series
Brittany Adair Beitzel
“Faith in the Journey”
November 16, 2025
7:00pm
Magic & Wonder Theater
Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Theatre (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.
Faith in the Journey is an evening of music that Brittany Adair Beitzel describes as more than just notes—it’s been her way of holding onto faith and finding joy and laughter, even in the hardest seasons. Sharing songs that mean the most to her, both old favorites and long-dreamed-of selections, Brittany hopes audiences will hear not only her story but also a reflection of their own journey, filled with hope, gratitude, and God’s enduring love.
Act 1
“My Days” from The Notebook - Ingrid Michaelson
“My White Knight” from The Music Man - Meredith Willson
“I’m Not Afraid Of Anything” from Songs For A New World - Jason Robert Brown
“What Baking Can Do” & “She used to be mine” From Waitress - Sara Bareilles, feat. Rachel Hughes
“In His Eyes” from Jekyll and Hyde- Frank Wildhorn and Leslie Bricusse, feat. Cassie Cummings
Diva medley
“Queenie was a blonde” from Wild Party - Andrew Lippa
“No Good Deed” from Wicked - Stephen Schwartz
“On My Own” from Les Misérables - Claude-Michel Schönberg, Alain Boublil, and Jean-Marc Natel
“Satisfied” from Hamilton - Lin Manuel Miranda
“Gimme Gimme” from Thouroughly Modern Millie - Jeanine Tesori and Dick Scanlan
“Phantom Of The Opera” from Phantom of the Opera - Andrew Lloyd Webber
“Pulled” from The Addams Family - Andrew Lippa
“Maybe This Time” from Cabaret - John Kander and Fred Ebb
“A Piece Of Sky” from Yentl - Michel Legrand, Alan Bergman, and Marilyn Bergman
Act 2
“If Heaven Never Was Promised To Me” - Andrae Crouch
“For Good” from Wicked - Stephen Schwartz feat. Kelsey Buffington
“I Surrender” - Celine Dion
“I Don’t Wanna Wait” - Paula Cole feat. Jacob Cummings
“Glad That You Were Born” from Seven Brides for Seven Brothers - feat. Cassie Cummings and Rachel Hughes
“Be Still My Soul / It Is Well” - Katharina von Schlegel / Philip Paul Bliss and Horatio G. Spafford. feat. Jacob Cummings
“God is in This Story / ‘Tis So Sweet to Trust in Jesus” - Big Daddy Weave and Katy Nichole / William J. Kirkpatrick and Louisa M. R. Stead, feat. Brooklyn Hilton, Lillian Rule, Mylee Tortolano, Alice O’Neil, Sophia Schmalhofer, Lacey Abel, Mary Frances Eschenwald
Special Guests
Rachel Hughes, Cassie Cummings, Kelsey Buffington, Jacob Cummings, Brooklyn Hilton, Lillian Rule, Mylee Tortolano, Alice O’Neil, Sophia Schmalhofer, Lacey Abel, Mary Frances Eschenwald
Accompanist
Ethan Gross
MEET Brittany
Brittany Adair Beitzel is deeply honored to share her cabaret, Faith in the Journey.
Originally from Huntington, WV, she has joyfully called Lancaster home for the past thirteen years. You may have seen her on the stage at Sight & Sound Theatres in productions such as JONAH, NOAH, MOSES, SAMSON, MIRACLE OF CHRISTMAS, JESUS, and QUEEN ESTHER. She has also been blessed to perform with Piercing Word, PRiMA Theatre, and to both perform and direct with Servant Stage Company.
For the past three years, Brittany has had the joy of directing for the Lancaster Academy of the Performing Arts, where she now also teaches and leads her own vocal studio. Pouring into her students—helping them find their voices, their confidence, and their love for the art—is one of her greatest passions.
Brittany holds a degree in Musical Theatre and Psychology from Liberty University. Faith in the Journey is both a celebration of God’s faithfulness and a joyful reflection on the songs that have shaped her life and story—a fun, heartfelt journey through music that has made her who she is today. It is her offering of gratitude for a life forever changed by grace.
“All my love to my husband, Aaron, and to my beautiful sons, Dawson and Theo. My life has been transformed in the most extraordinary ways since it became not about me, but about them—loving them, serving them, and seeing the world through their eyes. They are my daily reminder of what truly matters.”